Request for Interpretation (Amarr v Imperial Rep, Goldshire)
Moderators: (Shireroth) Court Historian, (Shireroth) Steward, (Shireroth) Kaiser
Re: Request for Interpretation (Amarr v Imperial Rep, Goldsh
Your Majesty -- For the sake of justice, Dr Krumsson has now returned. Perhaps the case could be considered now?
Count Rev Dr Spraki Krumsson Lla'i-Ašura of Azarea
Father of the Kaiseress, Ambassador of the Heavenly Light to the High King of Stormark
Ric from Sweden
Father of the Kaiseress, Ambassador of the Heavenly Light to the High King of Stormark
Ric from Sweden
-
- Posts: 752
- Joined: Wed Jan 18, 2012 11:55 pm
Re: Request for Interpretation (Amarr v Imperial Rep, Goldsh
The new Arbiter has taken his seat.
Loki IV, Kaiser of Shireroth
"Shireroth sumus. Tempus in parte nostrum est."
Duke of Goldshire
Count of Hallucination, Count of Illumination, Viscount of Monty Crisco
"Shireroth sumus. Tempus in parte nostrum est."
Duke of Goldshire
Count of Hallucination, Count of Illumination, Viscount of Monty Crisco
-
- Sea Elf, Sea Elf Run
- Posts: 2247
- Joined: Sat Dec 11, 2010 5:33 am
Re: Request for Interpretation (Amarr v Imperial Rep, Goldsh
OFFICIAL INTERPRETATIONS:
1. Is Adelsraad approval a criterion for the legal creation of subdivisions within a Duchy?
Adelsraad approval being a criterion for a variety of things is an important factor in a lot of situations in Shireroth. I suspect this will not be the first interpretation I have to give in regards to this criterion. In regards to the legal creation of subdivisions within a Duchy, the answer is yes, except in the case of Kaiseral decrees making subdivisions within a Duchy.
2. Is Goldshire's establishment of the realms of Khorze and Ynnraile as subdivisions legal?
The establishment of the realms of Khorze and Ynnraile can only be legal with either a) Adeslraad approval or b) Kaiseral approval. Either is quite easy to obtain and should pose no significant difficulties to the parties so interested. For a previous instance, see the request by Yours Truly to the Kaiser to form Baronetcies within the Raynor Isles; this is one of the two aforementioned ways to handle this situation in a proper manner.
Signed,
Arbiter Duke Gilles I
1. Is Adelsraad approval a criterion for the legal creation of subdivisions within a Duchy?
Adelsraad approval being a criterion for a variety of things is an important factor in a lot of situations in Shireroth. I suspect this will not be the first interpretation I have to give in regards to this criterion. In regards to the legal creation of subdivisions within a Duchy, the answer is yes, except in the case of Kaiseral decrees making subdivisions within a Duchy.
2. Is Goldshire's establishment of the realms of Khorze and Ynnraile as subdivisions legal?
The establishment of the realms of Khorze and Ynnraile can only be legal with either a) Adeslraad approval or b) Kaiseral approval. Either is quite easy to obtain and should pose no significant difficulties to the parties so interested. For a previous instance, see the request by Yours Truly to the Kaiser to form Baronetcies within the Raynor Isles; this is one of the two aforementioned ways to handle this situation in a proper manner.
Signed,
Arbiter Duke Gilles I
Re: Request for Interpretation (Amarr v Imperial Rep, Goldsh
Epic failure.
Malliki Tosha
Acting Xonuti of the Free State of Sanilla
Poluti Poki'i of Sanilla
Acting Xonuti of the Free State of Sanilla
Poluti Poki'i of Sanilla
Re: Request for Interpretation (Amarr v Imperial Rep, Goldsh
My preliminary opinion disagrees with the Arbiter on this. However because of doing actual law shit I can't give it in any detail at all right now. Just know that I dissent in my opinion and I'll provide it later.
Lord Montague
Balarak Alaiaon, Duke of Elwynn, Unifier of the Severed Duchy, Sequestrer of Disharmony
Also operating as Jean Carmichael, Duke of Evreaux, Speaker of the Imperial Assembly.
Oh and Eli Naveh too, Chief of the Ashkenatzan Naval Staff.
In Battle; Unbeatable. In Victory; Unbearable.
Balarak Alaiaon, Duke of Elwynn, Unifier of the Severed Duchy, Sequestrer of Disharmony
Also operating as Jean Carmichael, Duke of Evreaux, Speaker of the Imperial Assembly.
Oh and Eli Naveh too, Chief of the Ashkenatzan Naval Staff.
In Battle; Unbeatable. In Victory; Unbearable.
Re: Request for Interpretation (Amarr v Imperial Rep, Goldsh
As a citizen of Shireroth and resident of the same barony that Amarr is in, and count of Lakhesia which is affected by this opinion just like all other fiefs, I claim standing to challenge this opinion.
Therefore, I ask that the County of Amarr appeal this decision.
Therefore, I ask that the County of Amarr appeal this decision.
Malliki Tosha
Acting Xonuti of the Free State of Sanilla
Poluti Poki'i of Sanilla
Acting Xonuti of the Free State of Sanilla
Poluti Poki'i of Sanilla
Re: Request for Interpretation (Amarr v Imperial Rep, Goldsh
The County of Amarr notifies the Imperial Judex of its intention to appeal the ruling to higher resort. The appeal will be sent to the Kaiser April 5, 2012.
Kaspar Soleimân
EMIR OF SATHRATI
TO ERMO-RA-ARAEZELION
EMIR OF SATHRATI
TO ERMO-RA-ARAEZELION
Re: Request for Interpretation (Amarr v Imperial Rep, Goldsh
(I was meant to write that above thing)
Count Rev Dr Spraki Krumsson Lla'i-Ašura of Azarea
Father of the Kaiseress, Ambassador of the Heavenly Light to the High King of Stormark
Ric from Sweden
Father of the Kaiseress, Ambassador of the Heavenly Light to the High King of Stormark
Ric from Sweden
-
- Posts: 752
- Joined: Wed Jan 18, 2012 11:55 pm
Re: Request for Interpretation (Amarr v Imperial Rep, Goldsh
He must have been channeling you!
Loki IV, Kaiser of Shireroth
"Shireroth sumus. Tempus in parte nostrum est."
Duke of Goldshire
Count of Hallucination, Count of Illumination, Viscount of Monty Crisco
"Shireroth sumus. Tempus in parte nostrum est."
Duke of Goldshire
Count of Hallucination, Count of Illumination, Viscount of Monty Crisco